New Balance 574 Review

Introduction

The New Balance 574 has earned its reputation as one of the most iconic, influential, and enduring sneaker models of all time. First debuting in 1988, this classic kick celebrated its 35th anniversary in 2023 and continues to be a staple in sneaker culture.

With its vintage style, superior comfort, and incredible versatility, it's easy to see why the New Balance 574 remains one of the brand's best-selling lifestyle sneakers year after year.

This in-depth review will examine all aspects of this legendary shoe to see if it truly lives up to its iconic status over three decades later.

We'll be taking a close look at the key features and technologies, design and aesthetics, materials and construction quality, fit and sizing, comfort, performance, durability, and overall value and appeal of the New Balance 574. Let's dive in to see how this timeless classic holds up today.

Key Features and Technologies

The New Balance 574 may have a straightforward, old-school design, but it still delivers when it comes to innovation under the hood. Here are some of the key features and technologies that allow this classic kick to deliver reliable comfort and performance:

• ENCAP Midsole - The ENCAP midsole technology is a core component of many New Balance models. It combines a firm EVA foam rim on the outer edges with a softer compression-molded EVA foam core in the middle. This delivers soft cushioning and absorbs shock while also providing support and stability.
• C-CAP Midsole - Some colorways also incorporate C-CAP technology in the midsole, which uses a cushioning compound made of compression molded EVA foam for a softer, more flexible feel underfoot.
• Padded Collar - The plush, padded collar helps lock the heel in place and prevent slipping while adding next-level comfort around the ankle area.
• Removable Insole - The 574 comes with a lightweight, cushioned insole that can be removed and replaced with custom orthotics if needed.
• Rubber Outsole - The non-marking rubber outsole includes a lugged tread pattern that provides flexibility and reliable traction on varied surfaces.
• Premium Materials - From supple leather or suede uppers to breathable mesh panels, the 574 utilizes quality materials for a premium look and feel.

Design and Aesthetics

The New Balance 574 features a low-profile, vintage running shoe aesthetic that has remained largely unchanged over the decades.

Weighing in at around 11 ounces for a men's size 9, it strikes the perfect balance of feeling substantial yet light enough for all-day wear. Here are some design highlights:

• Retro Profile - The 574 has a vintage, old school look reminiscent of iconic running shoes from the 70s, 80s, and 90s. The suede overlays and mesh underlays provide rich texture and visual interest.
• Low-cut Design - With a low-cut collar that stops just below the ankle, the 574 offers freedom of movement while looking sleek and streamlined.
• Variety of Colorways - From understated black and white basics to vibrant neon accents, the 574 comes in an almost overwhelming array of colors to fit any style. New options are introduced seasonally.
• Minimal Branding - Just a simple "N" logo features on the sides, with some colorways also including a small New Balance logo on the heel. Clean and classic.
• Lace-Up Closure - Traditional lace-up ties ensure a secure, customizable fit.
• Unisex Styling - The 574 looks great on both men and women with its timeless, gender-neutral design. Sizing accommodates everything from narrow to wide width feet.

Materials

New Balance carefully selects quality materials for each component of the 574 to ensure comfort, durability, and flexibility. Here's an overview:

• Upper - Premium-grade suede and nylon mesh make up the upper, providing soft texture, breathability, and support. Eyelets are reinforced for strength.
• Lining - The interior lining is crafted from textile materials to wick away moisture and prevent irritation.
• Midsole - Compression molded EVA foam midsole cushioning keeps each step comfortable while remaining lightweight.
• Insole - A soft, removable foam insole adds underfoot comfort right out of the box. Can be replaced with custom orthotics.
• Outsole - The outsole uses non-marking rubber in a lugged tread pattern for shock absorption and reliable traction.
• Laces - Round, waxed cotton laces allow you to fine tune the fit while staying securely tied.
• Collar Lining - Plush foam collar lining prevents chafe and adds cushioning around the ankles.

New Balance thoughtfully sources each material to optimize comfort, flexibility, and durability.

Traction

The lugged rubber outsole equips the New Balance 574 with excellent traction on a variety of surfaces, both indoor and outdoor.

The raised lugs grip the ground, providing multi-directional traction that keeps you steady on your feet whether you're strolling city streets or tackling light trails.

Testers found the traction reliable across concrete, gym floors, track surfaces, grass, dirt trails, and more. Wet conditions do make the outsole a bit more slippery but the 574 still remains fairly grippy in slightly damp environments.

Just don't expect hardcore hiking shoe levels of traction. For everyday activities, the traction gets the job done well.

Cushioning

Plush cushioning makes the 574 one of the most comfortable retro-styled sneakers you can find. The ENCAP midsole technology provides soft yet responsive cushioning underfoot, absorbing shock and impact with each step.

The compression-molded EVA foam follows the contours of your foot for a custom feel while also keeping weight impressively low.

Reviewers found the cushioning strikes the perfect balance of being soft yet still responsive enough you don't feel disconnected from the ground.

The padded collar also adds pillowy comfort around the ankles to prevent rubbing and chafing during active use. For all-day wear, the 574 has cushioning that feels springy and supportive mile after mile.

Support

With its ENCAP midsole combining soft cushioning and firm stability rims, the New Balance 574 provides a moderate level of arch support suitable for most foot types.

The raised collar wraps securely around the ankle for lateral support and stability. While not designed for rigorous athletic activity, the 574 offers adequate arch and foot structure to accommodate casual walks, everyday wear, travel, and light workouts.

Reviewers with both high and neutral arches found the support comfortable for casual use. However, some noted those with very flat arches may want to consider more structured arch support.

Overall, the 574 aims to balance cushioning and flex with just enough support for versatile everyday wear.

Fit

The New Balance 574 runs true to size for most foot shapes. However, many wearers suggest ordering a half-size up for a little extra wiggle room, especially if you plan to wear them with thicker socks.

The 574 comes in a wider range of widths than most sneakers, accommodating narrow, standard, wide, and extra wide feet.

The lace-up closure also allows you to fine tune the secureness until you achieve your ideal fit. Break-in time is minimal thanks to the pliable suede and mesh upper.

The materials mold to your feet within just a few short wears. Once broken in, the fit feels like a customized slipper. Just be aware the materials will stretch and conform over time, so a snugger fit out of the box is ideal for long term wear.

Comfort

Supreme comfort makes the 574 a go-to for all-day wear. Reviewers across the board praise the plush feel from heel to toe.

The soft, flexible upper encases your foot in comfort without any pinch points or irritation. Underfoot, the ENCAP midsole technology provides pillowy yet responsive cushioning that eases every step.

The padded collar cradles your ankle to prevent any rubbing. Even after hours of wear, the 574 still feels as comfortable as when you first slipped them on.

The materials conform to your unique foot shape for a custom, cloud-like feel many describe as “walking on air.” While performance tech has advanced, the 574 exemplifies how old-school comfort never goes out of style.

Breathability

The combination of suede, nylon mesh, and textile interior lining make the New Balance 574 a fairly breathable shoe for casual use.

The mesh panels allow air flow over the top of your foot and heat to escape, keeping your feet cooler when temperatures rise. The lining wicks away perspiration to keep you dry.

Reviewers in warmer climates found their feet stayed adequately ventilated for walks around town or leisurely activities. However, those doing more strenuous exercise saw heat build-up in the toes that required taking breaks to air out their feet.

So while the 574 offers suitable ventilation for casual use, performance runners or serious athletes may want more air flow from technical mesh fabrics that actively circulate air.

For all-day wear in mild to warm conditions, the 574 breathes well enough to avoid swampy feet.

Durability

New Balance designed the 574 to stand the test of time, from the materials to construction methods. The premium suede upper holds its structure and resists scuffs.

Underneath, the EVA midsole retains its bounce even after extensive wear thanks to the compression molding process. The rubber outsole withstands abrasion remarkably well, showing minimal signs of wear unless used extensively for athletic activities.

Overall, the 574 ages gracefully, making it a sound investment that you'll be able to wear for years of comfortable use.

Many reviewers reported their pairs lasting 5+ years with minimal issues other than expected sole wear, speaking to the top-notch craftsmanship and materials used.

With proper care, the 574 will likely endure far longer than mass market sneakers, living up to its reputation as an enduring icon.

Water Resistance

The New Balance 574 offers moderate water resistance suitable for light rain or splashes but cannot withstand heavy downpours or being submerged.

The suede upper can repel small amounts of moisture but becomes saturated quite quickly. The mesh panels also allow water to permeate faster than solid leather or nubuck.

Once wet, the interior lining and foam insole retain moisture for longer than quick-drying synthetics.

Reviewers found the 574 held up fine in drizzles and puddles but became waterlogged and took a long time to fully dry out after heavy rain exposure.

So while it resists moisture well enough for brief outings in showers, those wanting a highly waterproof shoe should look for technical membranes and sealed seams. For all but the wettest conditions, the 574 provides adequate water protection.

Style

The New Balance 574 has a timeless retro style perfect for casual wear and versatile looks. It pairs well with everything from jeans, khakis, joggers, shorts, dresses, and leggings.

Both men and women can easily incorporate the classic sneaker silhouette into their wardrobe rotation.

Clean color palettes like navy, white, gray, and black go with any casual outfit while pops of color like neon yellow or sky blue make a fun statement.

Whether dressing up or down, the iconic design serves as a stylish anchor piece. Its forever trendy vintage vibes slot seamlessly into almost anyone's aesthetic. Few sneakers transcend trends and fads like the 574.

Brand Reputation

New Balance has built a reputation for quality craftsmanship and innovative technology across their performance and lifestyle models over the past century. Their "Made in USA" and "Made in UK" labels represent top-notch materials and construction.

New Balance also commits to social and environmental responsibility, including using sustainable materials and funding youth fitness programs. The brand has legions of loyal fans who trust their Consistent quality, fit, support and style.

The New Balance 574 embodies the brand's commitment to heritage designs that stand the test of time. Its 35+ years in production underscores the trust people place in this brand to deliver iconic American footwear.

Warranty and Guarantees

New Balance offers a 30-day comfort guarantee for a full refund or exchange if you are not satisfied with the comfort or fit of your 574s. This allows you to truly test them out for extended wear.

If any defects in materials or workmanship are found, New Balance will repair or replace them within two years of purchase date.

This demonstrates the brand's belief in the quality and durability of the 574. As long as you purchase from an authorized retailer, you can buy with confidence knowing these guarantees have you covered.

Value for Money

With most colorways priced between $80-120 USD, the New Balance 574 provides exceptional value given its quality construction, premium materials, legendary comfort, and iconic style. Few sneakers at this price point offer the same pedigree and level of craftsmanship.

The 574 costs a fraction of most designer sneaker brands but stands toe-to-toe with them in terms of comfort, style, and lasting wear.

Given some reviewers wear their 574s for 5+ years before needing a replacement, the cost per wear comes out to pennies.

For shoppers wanting a comfortable, supportive, on-trend sneaker that goes the distance without breaking the bank, the 574 is an unbeatable option that will earn compliments for years to come.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Timeless, retro style
• Superior comfort right out of the box
• Roomy toe box
• Excellent shock absorption
• Available in extended widths
• Accommodates orthotics
• Premium quality materials
• Exceptional durability and longevity
• Versatile, everyday wearability
• Great traction and grip
• Modest pricing given quality
• Trusted brand reputation

Cons

• Runs slightly narrow
• Minimal arch support
• Poor ventilation for high intensity exercise
• Suede stains require maintenance
• Long break-in period with some stiff colors
• Little ankle support for rigorous activity
• Not ideal for wide feet unless wide width purchased

Users' Ratings

The New Balance 574 earns consistently high marks and recommendations across consumer reviews.

On Amazon, it scores 4.5 out of 5 stars after nearly 15,000 global ratings. Praise centers around the "perfect balance of comfort and style" along with the vintage aesthetics. Many call them their "go-to casual sneaker" thanks to feeling like "walking on clouds."

The most common criticisms involve the narrow fit and lack of foot support compared to performance sneakers. Yet most agree the pros heavily outweigh any minor cons. Over 75% of reviewers give the 574 a full 5 star rating. It also ranks as a bestseller across footwear.

On Zappos, it earns a 4.5 out of 5 star average from over 3,700 reviews, with 93% saying they would recommend the 574 to a friend. Clearly this icon has stood the test of time by delivering on all fronts.

Comparison to Competitors

Vs. Nike Air Force 1: The AF1 has a bulkier, more structured basketball shoe vibe versus the vintage runner aesthetic of the 574. Nike's fit also runs narrower while the 574 accommodates wider feet. However, the AF1 does provide better ankle support. In terms of comfort, the 574 wins out with more responsive cushioning.

Vs. Adidas Stan Smith: The Stan Smith prioritizes minimalist styling over comfort and cushioning. Its low profile court style has less versatility than the heritage runner look of the 574. However, the Stan Smith does offer a wider toe box.

Vs. Reebok Club C 85: The Club C 85 comes the closest to matching the 574's old school styling and materials. But the Reebok model has a slimmer, less accommodating fit. The 574 provides a more comfortable break-in period and long term wear. However, some prefer the Club C 85's simple, tennis shoe-inspired look.

Vs. Converse Chuck Taylor All Star: As an iconic basketball sneaker, the Chuck Taylor compares more to the Air Force 1 in its structured, flat feel. Converse offers minimal cushioning compared to the 574's responsive ENCAP midsole. The retro styling appeals more with the NB 574 for casual wear.

Conclusion and Recommendation

Over 35 years after its debut, the New Balance 574 remains a comfortable, stylish sneaker icon that lives up to its legendary reputation. Very few models achieve this kind of enduring staying power and remain relevant across decades, footwear trends, and generations.

While performance tech continues advancing, the 574 exemplifies that superb comfort, quality construction, and vintage appeal never go out of style.

For shoppers seeking the complete package of cushioning, support, durability, and casual versatility at a fair price, the New Balance 574 earns an enthusiastic recommendation. 

ts rich heritage only adds to the appeal. Just be sure to size up a half size for the ideal relaxed fit this classic model was meant to deliver.

Alternatives

For those wanting a slightly different take on the vintage runner look, here are some recommended alternatives to consider:

• New Balance 997H - An "elevated" take on a retro runner with pig suede accents and a fresh cork footbed.
• New Balance 997S - Showcases premium materials and craftsmanship with a "Sporting Gentlemen" vibe.
• New Balance 327 - A lifestyle sneaker inspired by vintage running models like the 574.
• Nike Blazer Mid 77 - Iconic basketball silhouette with retro runner DNA and premium materials.
• Adidas Samba OG - A long-running indoor soccer kick with heritage styling.
• Saucony Jazz Original - Old school runner DNA in rainbow colorways.

Whichever you choose, New Balance and these other heritage sneakers combine comfort, quality, and classic appeal for the ultimate vintage-inspired lifestyle look.